+- HP Forums (https://www.hpmuseum.org/forum)
+-- Forum: HP Calculators (and very old HP Computers) (/forum-3.html)
+--- Forum: General Forum (/forum-4.html)
+--- Thread: Python math powers? (/thread-17708.html)
Python math powers? - robve - 11-15-2021 02:14 PM
CASIO fx-CG50 MicroPython v1.9.4 (but may not be specific to this calculator and Python version)
125**(1/3)
4.99999999999999
pow(125,1/3)
4.99999999999999
(-125)**(1/3)
(2.500000000000001+4.330127018922194j)
abs((-125)**(1/3))
5.00000000000001
pow(-125,1/3)
ValueError: math domain error
(-27)**(1/3)
(1.5+2.598076211353316j)
abs((-27)**(1/3))
3.0
- Rob
RE: Python math powers? - Guenter Schink - 11-15-2021 09:57 PM
Here's what my Prime G2 does:
(11-15-2021 02:14 PM)robve Wrote: CASIO fx-CG50 MicroPython v1.9.4 (but may not be specific to this calculator and Python version)Prime: 5.0
125**(1/3)
4.99999999999999
Quote:pow(125,1/3)Prime: 5.0
4.99999999999999
Quote:(-125)**(1/3)Prime: same
(2.500000000000001+4.330127018922194j)
Quote:abs((-125)**(1/3))Prime: 5.0
5.00000000000001
Quote:pow(-125,1/3)Prime: as in (-125)**(1/3)
ValueError: math domain error
I think that's almost all correct. Either 4.99.... or 5.0 probably depends on the specific implementation. There has been a lengthy discussion about 3rd root and operators precedence not so long ago.
I've checked the inputs in two other Python interpreters, one on my Samsung Tablet the other on in Windows. They show the same results except that none gives a clear 5.0 like the (probably cheating) Prime.
But all return a valid result for pow(-125,1/3) therefor I'd think this MicroPython on the CASIO is not complete.
HTH Günter
RE: Python math powers? - toml_12953 - 11-15-2021 10:31 PM
(11-15-2021 09:57 PM)Guenter Schink Wrote: Here's what my Prime G2 does:
(11-15-2021 02:14 PM)robve Wrote: CASIO fx-CG50 MicroPython v1.9.4 (but may not be specific to this calculator and Python version)Prime: 5.0
125**(1/3)
4.99999999999999
Quote:pow(125,1/3)Prime: 5.0
4.99999999999999
Quote:(-125)**(1/3)Prime: same
(2.500000000000001+4.330127018922194j)
Quote:abs((-125)**(1/3))Prime: 5.0
5.00000000000001
Quote:pow(-125,1/3)Prime: as in (-125)**(1/3)
ValueError: math domain error
I think that's almost all correct. Either 4.99.... or 5.0 probably depends on the specific implementation. There has been a lengthy discussion about 3rd root and operators precedence not so long ago.
I've checked the inputs in two other Python interpreters, one on my Samsung Tablet the other on in Windows. They show the same results except that none gives a clear 5.0 like the (probably cheating) Prime.
But all return a valid result for pow(-125,1/3) therefor I'd think this MicroPython on the CASIO is not complete.
HTH Günter
TI-nspire CX II:
125**(1/3)
5.000000000000002
pow(125,1/3)
5.000000000000002
(-125)**(1/3)
(2.500000000000001+4.330127018922195j)
abs((-125)**(1/3))
5.000000000000001
pow(-125,1/3)
(2.500000000000001+4.330127018922195j)