[FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - Printable Version +- HP Forums (https://www.hpmuseum.org/forum) +-- Forum: HP Calculators (and very old HP Computers) (/forum-3.html) +--- Forum: HP Prime (/forum-5.html) +--- Thread: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... (/thread-9868.html) [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - dg1969 - 01-06-2018 07:14 PM Hi, Here is an example of a system equations... degree mode is on... Code: ``` E1: R+T-P*SIN(-15)=0 E2: S-Q+P*COS(15)=0 E3: -A*T+P*(D*SIN(-15)-C*COS(15))+B*Q=0``` Unknowns are R, S and Q So in fact the 1rst eq give R and then we have S and Q with E2 and E3 Code: ``` A:=2.62 B:=25.88 C:=0.97 D:=1.84 T:=450 P:=-1400``` If I check only E2 and E3 The solutions for S and Q are OK: But if I try to solve the three equations in a single system (E1, E2 and E3 are check) and with the num view complete like these: The solve app change T and P !!! But T and P are not checked !! ? as you can see : R solution is OK but S and Q are not !!! The approx solutions are: R=-88 ; S=1383 and Q=-31 Any help are welcome... I do not understand what I'm doing wrong... RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - Carlos295pz - 01-06-2018 08:44 PM It seems to be just a problem of insertion of values, the calculations are correct. The App is inserting the solutions in the first boxes, it is not respecting the position of the selected boxes. RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - Carsen - 01-06-2018 09:17 PM I don't know what this unusual phenomenon is but it worked with my HP Prime perfectly. Every value is with its correct number. RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - Tim Wessman - 01-06-2018 11:47 PM Thanks for providing the files. Makes it easier to investigate. RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - dg1969 - 01-08-2018 03:25 PM (01-06-2018 08:44 PM)Carlos295pz Wrote:  It seems to be just a problem of insertion of values, the calculations are correct. The App is inserting the solutions in the first boxes, it is not respecting the position of the selected boxes. Yes indeed, well seen. The problem is now in very good hands. Potentially there is no more problem. RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - Helge Gabert - 01-08-2018 04:18 PM Are you sure that S should equal approx. 1383? With fsolve, I get approx. 1321 for S., with R and Q as you indicated above. RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - roadrunner - 01-08-2018 04:57 PM In the OP's code E2 is indicated as: E2: S-Q+P*COS(15)=0 But the screen shot shows E2 as: E2: S+Q+P*COS(15)=0 Could this be part of the problem? -road RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - Tim Wessman - 01-08-2018 05:15 PM Thank you for catching this. Indeed, the solution storage into the checked variables wasn't handling gaps in the checkmarks. This is now corrected! RE: [FW Beta3] Solve APP failed... Can't understand... - dg1969 - 01-10-2018 01:30 PM (01-08-2018 05:15 PM)Tim Wessman Wrote:  Thank you for catching this. Indeed, the solution storage into the checked variables wasn't handling gaps in the checkmarks. This is now corrected! Thank you Tim !