HP 39gs vs HP 50g

[Han]

(02-01-2017 01:54 AM)rprosperi Wrote:  

(01-31-2017 10:08 PM)vangelis Wrote:  Which do you think its a better option.

What do you plan to use the calculator for? Knowing that would make it easier to make specific recommendations.

The 50g is a FAR more capable machine, and has literally thousands of programs and 'how-to' tips on hundreds of websites. The 50g is used by practicing engineers all over the world, whereas the 39gs was built specifically for the High Scholl and College student.

While the 39gs can be programmed using 'applets', relatively few of them have been published (compared to 50g programs) however its difficult to compare them as the applets can be more larger and more complete programs including graphing and other features that would need to be built from scratch in the 50g.

The 39gs will be easier to learn, partly because it is limited to Algebraic notation. The 50g can use both Algebraic and RPN (actually a variation of RPN called RPL) and, while it does have a steeper learning curve, you will be able to do much more and have better control over your data and programs.

Except for educational use, most folks here would recommend the 50g over the 39gs, even thought the cost is higher, because it can do much more and it uses RPN/RPL, which is preferred by almost all HP Calculator fans.

Your feedback about these comments and details of your planned use will help to give you better and more specific advice.

Even for educational use, the 50G is a much better choice in my opinion. It also has an algebraic mode that makes it behave like other graphing calculators that have similar capabilities. So if you are unsure about RPN notation, don't let that bother you (you can switch between algebraic mode and RPN/RPL mode very easily through the mode menu). This way you can learn the much more efficient RPN entry method at your own pace.