SUBSTR indexes in free42

[mtern]

Hello, playing with the new string functions in free42 I notice that it seems SUBSTR uses an Y index starting from 0, while the X index starts from 1.
So to get the Nth character of a string or element of a list, you have N-1 in Y and N in X
Is it the expected behaviour?

Or maybe the intepretation is different: SUBSTR takes element from Y included to X excluded?

As a simple exercise, this is a reusable routine to get the nth string character or list element:

LBL "NTH"
FUNC 21
RCL ST X
1
-
X<>Y
SUBSTR
RTN

thank you
Mark

[Albert Chan]

(07-31-2021 01:01 PM)mtern Wrote:  Or maybe the intepretation is different: SUBSTR takes element from Y included to X excluded?

Yes. String index is 0-based, end excluded → string length = end - begin

[mtern]

(07-31-2021 03:50 PM)Albert Chan Wrote:  

(07-31-2021 01:01 PM)mtern Wrote:  Or maybe the intepretation is different: SUBSTR takes element from Y included to X excluded?

Yes. String index is 0-based, end excluded → string length = end - begin

Thank you for the clarification.
Mark