Post Reply 
Not returning correct Matrix Calculation
04-27-2021, 06:47 PM (This post was last modified: 04-27-2021 07:09 PM by Amer7.)
Post: #1
Not returning correct Matrix Calculation
My calculator is not giving me the correct matrix calculation.
Code:

2568.0000    -2568.00            1    0
2568.0000    2568.00000    0    1
3852.1284    -2568.00            1    0
2568.0000    3852.12840    0    1
3536.9834    -3411.36           1    0
3411.3569    3536.98344    0    1

That is Matrix A

Matrix O 
-4851346.102
-6513502.217
-4850456.274
-6513809.817
-4850472.619
-6513149.860

TRN(A)*A should be
58770372.8276     0.0000              9957.1118    8547.3569
0.0000                   58770372.8276     -8547.3569    9957.1118
9957.1118           -8547.3569      3.0000            0.0000
8547.3569            9957.1118      0.0000            3.0000

Inverse(TRN(A)*A) should be
7.29974E-07    -1.81352E-22    -0.002422813    -0.002079784
-2.53893E-21    7.29974E-07    0.002079784    -0.002422813
-0.002422813    0.002079784    14.30029098    0
-0.002079784    -0.002422813    -4.54077E-14    14.30029098

But I get different numbers than in Excel, im using Shift + devide key to inverse. Can someone explain, and later in my calculation i get wrong answer because of Inverse mistake.

TRN(A)*O should be
-1.03972E+11
-23394687040
-1.46E+07
-1.95E+07

- I get this OK, But my issue is here

M=( Inverse((TRN(A)*A) * (TRN(A)*O)
-0.6929740
0.2395352
4853740.802
6514666.637

But I get:
0.6929740
-0.2395352
-4853740.802
-6514666.637
Can someone explain why this is happening? - Im not writing a program im manually doing the calculation on Home screen.

And later 
A*M+O should be
0.017
-0.011
-0.023
-0.017
0.006
0.027

but I get
0.03314
-0.01158 
etc. - WRONG

I have tried to multiply the M matrix with (-1) but again calculation of O seems wrong.

What is the best command for finding Inverse matrix ? same happens when i use inv(Matrix that i want to invert)
   
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
04-27-2021, 08:09 PM
Post: #2
RE: Not returning correct Matrix Calculation
Hi, Amer7

Tried this in Numpy, Excel numbers were wrong.

>>> from numpy import *
>>> A = array([
... [2568.0000, -2568.00 , 1, 0],
... [2568.0000, 2568.00000, 0, 1],
... [3852.1284, -2568.00 , 1, 0],
... [2568.0000, 3852.12840, 0, 1],
... [3536.9834, -3411.36 , 1, 0],
... [3411.3569, 3536.98344, 0, 1]])
>>> B = dot(transpose(A), A)
Code:
>>> print B
[[  5.87703727e+07  -1.08281943e+01   9.95711180e+03   8.54735690e+03]
 [ -1.08281943e+01   5.87703941e+07  -8.54736000e+03   9.95711184e+03]
 [  9.95711180e+03  -8.54736000e+03   3.00000000e+00   0.00000000e+00]
 [  8.54735690e+03   9.95711184e+03   0.00000000e+00   3.00000000e+00]]
>>> print linalg.inv(B)
[[  7.29974488e-07   3.48034952e-13  -2.42281154e-03  -2.07978531e-03]
 [  3.48034952e-13   7.29972621e-07   2.07977844e-03  -2.42280733e-03]
 [ -2.42281154e-03   2.07977844e-03   1.43002735e+01   1.61304069e-05]
 [ -2.07978531e-03  -2.42280733e-03   1.61304069e-05   1.43002770e+01]]
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
04-27-2021, 08:20 PM (This post was last modified: 04-27-2021 08:35 PM by Amer7.)
Post: #3
RE: Not returning correct Matrix Calculation
Thank you Albert for numerous replies, I get the same numbers as you on my calculator. I guess something is wrong in Excel ( all formulas seemed ok). - I really doubt these are calculations from the teacher. The excel all matches up, with control calculations. Even my friends that use TI get the same numbers
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
04-27-2021, 10:56 PM
Post: #4
RE: Not returning correct Matrix Calculation
(04-27-2021 08:20 PM)Amer7 Wrote:  I guess something is wrong in Excel ( all formulas seemed ok).

It is possible the problem is not Excel.
From your attached screenshot, there were a picture suggesting A51 = A62, A61 = -A52.

Your provided A (row 5 and row 6) does not match this symmetrical pattern.
Not terribly off, but enough to mess up the numbers.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
04-28-2021, 05:25 AM
Post: #5
RE: Not returning correct Matrix Calculation
(04-27-2021 10:56 PM)Albert Chan Wrote:  
(04-27-2021 08:20 PM)Amer7 Wrote:  I guess something is wrong in Excel ( all formulas seemed ok).

It is possible the problem is not Excel.
From your attached screenshot, there were a picture suggesting A51 = A62, A61 = -A52.

Your provided A (row 5 and row 6) does not match this symmetrical pattern.
Not terribly off, but enough to mess up the numbers.

I have found the Issue, Im not sure why this happens. When number in column F have in front of them - ( minus, aka they are negative) Inverse matrix is not going to be the same as in Excel.
So when I input O matrix as all positive numbers I get inverse matrix correct.
And in last matrix calculation ( excel uses formula example (trn(A)*N) + O and when I adjust this to (trn(A)*N) - O I get everything correct.

I'm not sure why this difference is happening between calculator and Excel.
-Downloaded a virtual TI Nspire to check, they also get the same Matrix as we on our HP Prime.
-So its something querk of Excel.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)